Brooklyn, NY

Every figure
has a story
waiting
to be found.

A curated archive of vintage toys, rare figures, and objects of nostalgia—carefully sourced and thoughtfully displayed on Brooklyn's McDonald Avenue.

Curated vintage toy collection on wooden shelves
New arrivals weekly

500+

Pieces in stock

Brooklyn

Since 2018

Close-up of vintage collectible figure
Scroll

Objects of
deliberate curation

Each piece is individually assessed for authenticity, condition, and narrative value before finding its place in our collection.

Vintage action figures from the 1970s and 80s
View selection

Vintage Action Figures

1960s–1990s · In box & loose

Antique dolls and dollhouse miniatures
View selection

Dolls & Miniatures

Antique · Porcelain · Tin litho

Classic die-cast vehicles and model cars
View selection

Die-Cast & Models

Matchbox · Hot Wheels · Dinky

Vintage board games and puzzles
View selection

Board Games & Puzzles

Rare editions · Complete sets

Anime and manga collectible figures
View selection

Anime & Manga

Figurines · Bandai · Good Smile

Vintage educational and STEM toys
View selection

Educational & STEM

Science kits · Construction sets

Pinocchio Collectibles storefront on McDonald Avenue, Brooklyn
Close-up of curated collectible display shelf

A passion for
preserved play

Pinocchio Collectibles began as a personal pursuit—an obsession with the objects that shaped childhoods across generations. What started as weekend estate sales and flea markets has grown into a dedicated space on McDonald Avenue where collectors and curious visitors alike can wander through decades of crafted imagination.

We believe that a well-preserved toy is more than nostalgia. It is evidence of care—someone's attention to detail, a moment of joy frozen in plastic or wood or tin. Our collection spans mid-century tin litho, 1970s action figures, hand-painted porcelain dolls, and rare anime figures, each selected for its story and condition.

Whether you're searching for a specific piece to complete a collection or simply want to experience the quiet pleasure of browsing something genuinely special, we welcome you.

8+

Years in Brooklyn

100%

Authenticity guaranteed

Local

Community focused

Come see
what's new

Our showroom is small by design—intimate enough that every piece gets the attention it deserves. Walk-ins are always welcome; appointments are recommended for bulk inquiries or selling consignments.

Address

1814 McDonald Avenue
Brooklyn, NY 11223

Phone

(718) 645-2573

Hours

Tue – Sat: 11:00 AM – 6:00 PM
Sun: 12:00 PM – 5:00 PM
Mon: Closed

Map showing Pinocchio Collectibles location in Brooklyn, NY

1814 McDonald Ave

Brooklyn, NY 11223

Open in Google Maps

Have a piece
to sell or trade?

We're always interested in acquiring well-preserved collectibles. Whether you have a single rare figure or an entire collection to part with, reach out and we'll arrange a time to view your items.

Is this your business?This is my business