A curated archive of vintage toys, rare figures, and objects of nostalgia—carefully sourced and thoughtfully displayed on Brooklyn's McDonald Avenue.
500+
Pieces in stock
Brooklyn
Since 2018
Each piece is individually assessed for authenticity, condition, and narrative value before finding its place in our collection.
1960s–1990s · In box & loose
Antique · Porcelain · Tin litho
Matchbox · Hot Wheels · Dinky
Rare editions · Complete sets
Figurines · Bandai · Good Smile
Science kits · Construction sets
Pinocchio Collectibles began as a personal pursuit—an obsession with the objects that shaped childhoods across generations. What started as weekend estate sales and flea markets has grown into a dedicated space on McDonald Avenue where collectors and curious visitors alike can wander through decades of crafted imagination.
We believe that a well-preserved toy is more than nostalgia. It is evidence of care—someone's attention to detail, a moment of joy frozen in plastic or wood or tin. Our collection spans mid-century tin litho, 1970s action figures, hand-painted porcelain dolls, and rare anime figures, each selected for its story and condition.
Whether you're searching for a specific piece to complete a collection or simply want to experience the quiet pleasure of browsing something genuinely special, we welcome you.
8+
Years in Brooklyn
100%
Authenticity guaranteed
Local
Community focused
Our showroom is small by design—intimate enough that every piece gets the attention it deserves. Walk-ins are always welcome; appointments are recommended for bulk inquiries or selling consignments.
Address
1814 McDonald Avenue
Brooklyn, NY 11223
Phone
(718) 645-2573
Hours
Tue – Sat: 11:00 AM – 6:00 PM
Sun: 12:00 PM – 5:00 PM
Mon: Closed
We're always interested in acquiring well-preserved collectibles. Whether you have a single rare figure or an entire collection to part with, reach out and we'll arrange a time to view your items.